Wednesday, 10 July 2013

#Origin 2013: QLD still awesome... unless? | Maroons Game 3 Team Analysis

QLD Team Game 3: Still a prop short... Still pretty awesome.

2013 NRL Premiership

By W D Nicolson - July 10, 2013

The DECIDER is Wednesday week at a sold-out ANZ Stadium - so www.wdnicolson.com gives the Game 3 QLD team a once over. NSW Team Analysis here

Things went to plan in Game 2 - but QLD miss a trick for The Decider?
CURRENT NRL LADDER #NRLTweetPOTY Votes
Probably not.

When you win Game 2 like QLD did (which was not too dissimilar to NSW's victory in Game 1 most QLDers seem to forget) then you don't have to make any changes at the selection table.

And QLD didn't.

But NSW had to make changes going into Game 2 with Jarryd Hayne hurt, James Tamou suspended and Blake Ferguson... being Blake Ferguson when on the terps.

The Hayne loss was catastrophic for NSW (and he won't be there in Game 3 - which as we explain here - hurts) but QLD have refused to bring in another prop for Game 3 and I think they've missed a trick.

Let's look a the opening sets of Game 1 and 2 shall we?

Monday, 8 July 2013

#Origin 2013: NSW are stuffed... unless? | Blues Game 3 Team Analysis

NSW Team Game 3: Hayne is... was, the indispensable one

2013 NRL Premiership

By W D Nicolson - July 8, 2013

The DECIDER is Wednesday week at a sold-out ANZ Stadium - so www.wdnicolson.com gives the Game 3 NSW team a once over. QLD Team Analysis here

Hayne - not Bird or Gallen was the player NSW couldn't lose
CURRENT NRL LADDER #NRLTweetPOTY Votes
Even before NSW coach Laurie Daley named his squad for Game 3 on Sunday afternoon - everyone knew that fullback... err winger Jarryd Hayne was not going to play for Parramatta in Round 17's Monday Night Football game against Manly on July 8, the final tune-up opportunity for his troublesome hamstring before The Decider.

But it seemed like he would be given every chance to prove he was fit for Game 3 on Wednesday week July 17...

Now at approximately 1pm on Monday - some 9 days before Game 3 - Hayne has undergone a fitness test and has been ruled out.

NSW team-mates Hayne and McManus in 2009
Yep - Hayne is out of The Decider.

And now it looks like NSW are too.

It was bad enough to see Daley keep Josh Dugan in the #1 jersey (despite saying 'oh we'll play them both there during Game 3') instead of Hayne, but now James McManus is thrown back into the deep end of the pool... and NSW are fresh out of floatation devices.

I was chatting with my flat-mate last night about who NSW couldn't afford to lose for Game 3 and Hayne was the name we both jumped on as the answer. Sure fellow injury carrying New South Welshmen Greg Bird and Paul Gallen are the 'heart and soul' types of the Blues team but neither have the class that wins the game when it is there to be won.

Bird and Gallen bleed for the Blues and their effort is astounding every time they put on the NSW jersey - but effort can be somewhat replaced... the class of Hayne?

Not so much.

McManus will have a dig, he might even score a try - he's really really good at finishing half chances on the wing. But Hayne is the guy who CREATES those half chances.

The proof in the pudding as it were is how much poise James Maloney and Mitchell Pearce had in Game 1.

Sunday, 7 July 2013

#Origin 2013: If Bird and Gallen are out - what do NSW do for Game 3?

NSW Options Game 3: IF Gallen and Bird withdraw

2013 NRL Premiership

By W D Nicolson - July 7, 2013

The DECIDER is Wednesday week at a sold-out ANZ Stadium - but with fresh injuries on the scene for NSW - www.wdnicolson.com looks at the options for the Blues at the selection table.

Who gets the call for Game 3 for the Blues?
CURRENT NRL LADDER #NRLTweetPOTY Votes
NSW skipper Paul Gallen is still no better than a 50/50 chance of playing on Wednesday week in Origin 3 and the Blues were dealt another blow with backrower Greg Bird damaging ankle ligaments in the Gold Coast's loss to the Panthers in Darwin this weekend.

At this stage Gallen has said he won't test the foot out until next weekend - meaning he will be picked but a shadow player will also be selected. Bird says his moon boot is just precautionary but he also says that he was serious pain when injuring the ankle on his first run.

Gut feel right now is both are named but both withdraw...

While Jarryd Hayne is expected to play in Game 3 - he won't play in Monday Night Football for Parramatta. The Blues will get James Tamou back - at the expense of Aaron Woods... but that move has been decided before Gallen's fitness is determined.

EDIT: Obviously we wrote this early Sunday, and the final team was named Sunday afternoon.

Here is the 20 man NSW Squad for Game 3:
Dugan, Morris, Jennings, Morris, Hayne, Maloney, Pearce, Gallen (c), Farah (vc), Tamou, Lewis, Hoffman, Bird. Bench: Fifita, Merrin, Reynolds, Watmough; Woods, McManus, Cordner.
So we know for sure that Gallen, Hayne and Bird are far from certainties to play, with Woods on standby for Gallen, McManus for Hayne and Cordner for Bird.

BACK TO THE PRE-TEAM NAMED ARTICLE below:
So if Gallen is out - who comes in?